Which QB Has The Best Chance Of Winning Their First Super Bowl?

The interesting, sometimes absurd, always entertaining, “did he really just ask that?” types of questions.

Which NFL Quarterback Has The Best Chance Of Winning Their First Super Bowl In 2012-2013?

In what has been repeatedly labeled as a “quarterback-dominated” league, Tom Brady, Ben Roethlisberger, Drew Brees, Aaron Rodgers, and the Manning brothers have stood out among the rest. Those are the active starters who have found a way to win the big game, some more than once.

After those elite guys, there is a significant gap before you hit the next batch of solid quarterbacks. Many of them are consistent stat fillers, and are decent options for fantasy, but they haven’t been able to finish the job at this point in their careers. Which of the following quarterbacks who have yet to win a championship have the best chance of getting a ring this season?

1. Philip Rivers
2. Joe Flacco
3. Alex Smith
4. Michael Vick
5. Matt Ryan
6. Tony Romo
7. Matt Schaub
8. Matthew Stafford

1. Philip Rivers may be the most talented at the quarterback position out of everyone else on the list. He is consistently in the top 10 for all major passing statistics, and he has a very good squad to work with this year. Some may argue that the Chargers were the hottest team in the league in the second half of the season last year. Rivers definitely has what it takes to become a part of the elite group. But, like everyone else on the list, it will come down to execution.

2. Flacco’s been pretty close, but the competition over the last few years in the AFC has been too tough. In a conference that’s been dominated by the Patriots and Steelers, Flacco’s Ravens are one of the few other teams that are expected to contend each year. With the help of one of the best defenses on the list, a healthy Ray Rice, and a solid receiving corp, Flacco will most likely have another deep run in the playoffs this upcoming season.

3. Like Flacco, Alex Smith has the luxury of a dominant defense to make his journey to the Super Bowl even more realistic. And also like Flacco, Smith saw his team come up just short in the conference title game. One of the more underrated players in the league, Smith now has a brand new weapon in Randy Moss to go along with other exciting receivers. He proved he can get the job done through the air in crunch time last year in the playoffs against New Orleans. If Frank Gore can have another productive season on the ground, Smith and the 49ers will be a big threat.

4. Michael Vick hopes to get his “potential to be a dynasty” Eagles squad into the playoffs this year, after a disappointing first season. The Eagles seemed to find the winning formula late last year, but it was just a case of too little too late. Vick will try to be the leader Philadelphia needs him to be this year, as he rallies the troops together in a season he already stated was dedicated to head coach Andy Reid.

5. The Falcons have been a pretty solid team since Matt Ryan took over as the quarterback, but they haven’t made that jump into the elite category. Playing in one of the tougher divisions, Ryan will rely on his two main weapons, Roddy White and Michael Turner, to dig his way deep into the playoffs and try to become the next name to join the prestigious group of Super Bowl winners.

6. Tony Romo is the most criticized quarterback in the game. Classified as a gunslinger, he is one of those players not afraid to make the big throw. Unfortunately for him and the Cowboys, that usually has ended up in a game-changing interception, ultimately contributing to numerous letdown seasons. Romo is a great fantasy football option, good for compiling many passing yards and a fair share of touchdowns throughout the season, but high expectations constantly surround America’s team. Romo can keep putting up impressive numbers and 100+ QB ratings, but he is now at a point in his career where he will be judged on only one thing.

7. Last year marked a big milestone for the Texans, as they made the playoffs for the first time in franchise history. While Schaub was injured down the stretch, he has proven that he can keep up with the top quarterbacks in the league. With arguably both the top receiver and running back alongside him, only time will tell if this team can compete against the powerhouse AFC teams such as New England, Pittsburgh, and Baltimore.

8. Matthew Stafford probably has the worst chance of getting to the big game out of the other guys on the list, but that’s not to say his time won’t come a few seasons from now. The Lions have quickly went from a joke to one of the most exciting teams to watch in the NFL. Like the Texans, they became a fresh new team to show its face in the playoffs last year (first time since 1999). Stafford needs to stay healthy if they want to improve. The Lions are hoping the Stafford-Megatron combo will be dominant for years to come.

Other reasonable candidates: Cam Newton, Jay Cutler, Andy Dalton, Mark Sanchez/Tim Tebow

My pick: Alex Smith. I went more with the team surrounding him over his individual skill-set. Rivers and Romo might be the most talented on the list, but I like the 49ers chances this year. Flacco is a close second.

Sports Without Charm. BaltimoreSportsReport.com features fan coverage and analysis of the Baltimore Orioles, Baltimore Ravens, Washington Capitals, Maryland Terrapins and Towson Tigers.

10 Comments

  1. MGW

    August 14, 2012 at 10:48 am

    I think spy said it in another post, the only thing holding back Flacco and the Ravens is the coaching staff. I’ve said it for years and now I’m finding more and more folks who have finally come to realize it also. This is a talented team who has come one or two plays away from going to the Super Bowl the last few years. Naive fans look at the Lee Evans’ drop as the cause last year, but why was a guy with 5 catches all year the featured receiver with the super bowl on the line? Why was Billy Cundiff sprinting on the field from the opposite end zone during a Chinese fire drill which resulted in him missing the game tying field goal and also resulted in a coaching staff keeping a timeout in their back pocket? Maybe Flacco and company can do enough this year to overcome this staff…I hope so.

  2. Chris

    August 14, 2012 at 11:41 am

    Out of that list I would say either Flacco, Alex Smith, or Matt Schaub. The Ravens are usually contenders every year. The 49ers defense can carry them although their offense should be better as well. The Texans on paper look to be one of the two or three best teams in the AFC (although Schaub being injury prone doesn’t help). I don’t really like the others with the possible exception of Stafford. The Chargers, Eagles, Falcons, and Cowboys are all underachievers that collapse down the stretch or in the playoffs. The Lions show promise but they (and Stafford) need to prove they can take that next step into and through the playoffs.

  3. spy

    August 15, 2012 at 9:27 am

    Thanks for the recognition MGW , it’s good to see I’m not alone in my thinking,,,,,,,,,,,I actually think it is Rodgers turn again , I would love to see Flacco win one but the coaching staff has really stacked the cards against him with this poor excuse for an O-line,and do you honestly think Harbaugh and Cameron can out-think the opposition ? In a year where the defense will be less than stellar the offense will be asked to step it up , too bad Harbaugh can’t ‘coach’em up…………………it may be a long season , In hope not……………..

  4. 9inchnails

    August 15, 2012 at 6:03 pm

    The coaching staff has ZERO to do with us not winning a Super Bowl. The defense has aged. Ray Lewis is not a top 5, or top 10 or top 20 defeder any more. we have no pass rush. We have as many holes that need plugged on our O-line as Spy’s 3 lady friends. Our special teams ai just average. LaDarius Webb has been burned more times than the Intimidator when he was a teenager. I will say it again, Matt Ryan said, “We knew we could throw on them and we did for an entire half. Their pass rush was just mediocre and we felt we could run all over them.” Harbaugh and company is at less fault than Ozzie and the guys that put the team together. Lee Evans was a great pick up. If you are looking to place blame see Brian Billich and the years wasting away with freaking Kyle Boller, getting rid of Dilfer for Elvis, $15 subs at Cpt Harvey’s… That’s where you start to place nlame…

    • spy

      August 16, 2012 at 9:34 am

      Hey Incher,,,,,,,It looks like you think they shouldn’t even have coaches,,,,,,,,don’t you think the coaching and their respective schemes have anything to do with winning ?

      The biggest difference between winning and loosing in the NFL is your q-back and your coaching staff,,,,,,,,,,parity in the NFL has made this very real even though you don’t believe it,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

      • 9inchnails

        August 16, 2012 at 12:02 pm

        You are right, the draft, a slow defense, no secondary and a piss poor pass rush is usurped by bad coaching.
        Using your logic, any team with good coaching would win all the time. You and I both know that’s false.

        • spy

          August 18, 2012 at 9:57 am

          Hey incher , I didn’t say they were the only difference , I said they were the biggest difference,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,if all those things happen to one team no amount of good coaching can overcome that,,,,,,,,,,,,,I do agree with you about the Ravens chances this year , they do appear tp be rather thin,,,,,,,,,,,,I still don’t know how ozzie gets a free pass all the time , when you look at his recent drafting and the state of the o-line for the past four years it is pitiful…………
          Good comments all……………..

    • Chris

      August 16, 2012 at 1:56 pm

      Lardarius Webb burned more times then the Intimidator? Lol. If you’re going to troll at least make your arguments real enough to piss people off.

  5. Anvil

    August 16, 2012 at 9:17 am

    I agree with spy, I think this is the year for Rodgers to add to his collection. The Packers have the tools to go all the way and a coach who can coach em up and make the run. Too bad Harbs can’t do the same.

    • spy

      August 16, 2012 at 9:35 am

      Smart man…………..