The firestorm was expected.
Buck Showalter opted to keep Zach Britton in the bullpen in the bottom of the 11th inning, inserting Ubaldo Jimenez instead. The end result was Jimenez giving up a three-run home run to Edwin Encarnacion on a walk off that sent Birdland into a complete state of shock.
And then, the hate started.
“Why is Britton not in the game?”
“Why did Nolan Reimold pinch hit for Hyun Soo Kim?”
“Why is Reimold getting an at bat before Pedro Alvarez?”
“What is Buck thinking?”
The real question should be, where the hell were the bats?
It was an all-too-common theme of the season. The Orioles live and die by the long ball and it was never more apparent than last night. Mark Trumbo gave Baltimore their only hope of the night in his first – and likely last with the O’s – postseason appearance with a two-run shot in the fourth. Two runs are not going to keep the job done on most nights, but especially come the playoffs.
The Orioles had four hits on the night. The last of which came in the sixth inning on a Manny Machado single. After that? Eight ground outs, a fly out and six strikeouts. The most embarrassing being Reimold’s strikeout on three straight pitches as a replacement for Kim as the last out for the Orioles.
To make matters worse, Reimold bobbled a ball hit to him in the 11th that would have likely doomed the Orioles regardless if Jimenez allowed the bomb to Encarnacion. Just like that, everyone turned on Buck for putting Reimold and Jimenez in the game.
The postgame press conference was nothing but questions about Britton. The Orioles closer commented after the game that he was “disappointed” not to play, but “it is not his call.” The media blasted Buck for not using the best relief pitcher in baseball.
Some want to blame Michael Bourn for the error that allowed a run to score. It was a bad read without a doubt, but Bourn saved a run earlier in the game on a ball that Trumbo would have had no chance to get. Even after the error, it was still a tie ball game for either team to take.
Then, there are the people chastising the decision to bring Ubaldo into the game. He has been the Orioles best pitcher in the month of September, and there were PLENTY of fans who were critical of him not taking the mound over Tillman. Most starting pitchers need an inning to figure things out, but he was not afford that by coming in late in the game against the Blue Jays best hitters.
All that said, the Orioles should have not been in that position. This is the time of the season where the bats need to come alive, and after scoring 16 runs against the New York Yankees, it looked as if they were hot heading into the playoffs. The final 16 outs were brutal to watch.
I cannot stress it enough: FOUR hits. In a playoff game. It’s not enough to get it done, regardless whether Ubaldo or Britton is on the mound. The Orioles had 10 other innings to win the game and could not do it.
Going forward, the Orioles must become a more complete team. The San Francisco Giants have been one of the best franchises in the past decade because of their ability to beat you in a variety of ways. They can win by the long ball. They can also play small ball. Baltimore has the pieces in the rotation and bullpen, but Showalter and Dan Duquette must find a way to score runs when the power hitters are off.
The most gut wrenching moment of the evening was listening to the great Joe Angel close out the radio broadcast by saying, “Go Ravens.” I do not like these guys. I love them. It was not the result we wanted, but thank you for a memorable season Buck and company. Cannot wait to see what 2017 brings us.
Yep. Yep. Yep. Yep.
I don’t blame Buck for not going to Britton. I blame the bats for putting him in a position where he had to make that decision.
The focus this offseason needs to be balancing out the lineup.
I agree…..our bats were flat…Our problem was not hitting & NOT scoring runs!
Also, I know I might be crazy for saying it, but Britton’s value is through the roof. They have to think about trading him.
Yeah, at least see what you can get for Britton.
No, it was a bad move.
We said it all season. Home runs are fun and exciting but base hits win games. Great base running and small
ball are part of the game but not ours!!
Love the O’s but this was predictable when you HAVE to hit the long ball to win.
I 100% agree.
First and foremost Buck and company love you all and thank you for a great season!
Second of all, excellent article and pitching did not loose this game, our bats did. It is ridiculous that we only had 4 hits in a play off game.
It takes the efforts of a team to win, not just a few. That is why a pitcher has 8 players on the field with him.
Go O’s
Amen to that- we didn’t show up
There’s not one single source to fault.
The O didn’t show up, Ubaldo reverted to mid-season form, Buck took out Kim in favor of 3 straight strikes and 2 unplayed balls on D (aka Reimold)… All of that shit added up equals a loss, not one specific thing.
I’m a Kim guy, but he’s 0 for the season against lefties, Reimold is 4-8 against Liriano, and is better defensively than Kim. I don’t fault him for that move at all. Although, he probably could have pinch hit with Mancini and then put Stubbs or Reimold in for Mancini in left. Stubbs was 0-2 off of Liriano.
He’s 0 for ‘the season’ against lefties because buck never lets him face them and get any swings in. The actual stat line is 0 for 18.
There you go, Baseball Reference didn’t have his splits and I didn’t look at FanGraphs. I know Buck didn’t let him bat against lefties…and I’m guessing there’s a reason for that.
Look, again, I’m a Kim guy. I was in his corner before we even signed him. I own his Doosan Bears jersey. I want him to get as many bats against LHP as possible this spring, but from the numbers we have at the major league level it wasn’t a good matchup. Plus he was 0-4 in the game. Again, Reimold was 4-8 against Liriano.
Still waiting for the in-laws to ship my DSB jersey over from Korea. Can’t find authentic ones here, and their store only ships within Korea. 🙁
Disappointing game. But you are right. If bats had been there.,,then we would have won
Dustin Collins
Buck was probably playing the odds that the O’s would get a lead in their at bat, and he could bring Britton onto shut down the Jays in the bottom half of whatever inning, instead of burning him in a tie. Hindsight is 20/20, and there are 10 other AL teams that would love to have been playing last night. They definitely won (and lost) as a team this season.
Alex Bernstein
Totally agree. If Britton comes in a fires 2 perfect innings and they still don’t get the bats going, then what? Critics would question why he went to Britton so early. Glad to at least hear and read that the fans still care about this team.
Lack of offense not Buck’s pitching decision
Amen.
could not agree more
Pitching, pitching, pitching, pitching, pitching!!!! Angelos will you EVER put money into pitching???? EVERY Year they do well… It’s the SAME STORY. !!